Welcome to Aniello's Pizzeria
Aniello's Pizzeria, located at 68 E Market St in Corning, NY, is a beloved culinary gem celebrated for its exceptional New York-style pizza. Renowned for its crispy crust and quality ingredients, this pizzeria offers both traditional and Sicilian varieties that delight pizza aficionados. Customers rave about the warm, inviting service and the efficiency that makes dining here a breeze for families and friends alike. With its cozy atmosphere and outstanding dishes—like the well-loved supreme pizza and fantastic sandwiches—Aniello's Pizzeria is not just a stop on the way to the Finger Lakes, but a destination worth returning to time and again.
Aniello's Pizzeria: Reviews & Ratings
Pit stop on way to finger lakes. Great pizza. Friendly local and efficient service. Will be back. Cute little town too.
We came with four adults and two kids who were served and seated right away. Ordered at the counter and then served at the table. All excellent. Pizza crust was very crispy and delicious. Supreme pizza was great!
You normally wouldn't expect such great food from a pizza place but it's amazing. They also kept all our food warm in the pizza oven so that when they brought it out for the five of us it was all nice and hot. Traditional and Sicilian pizza. The bread on the sandwiches is fantastic.
I grew up in the NYC area. This is the best Brooklyn style pizza I've had outside of NYC. The quality of the ingredients is excellent. The crust has that perfect balance of soft and crunchy with great flavor.
Absolutely 10/10 pizza. I live out of state and it's next to impossible to find a NY style pizza as good as this anywhere. Prices are also very reasonable. Definitely worth the stop and if I'm back in town I will absolutely be coming back for more.
This establishment is a cozy, cafeteria style restaurant where you order and pay at the counter and they bring your food to your table. Our server was Rae, who was lovely, helpful and very patient (we were very indecisive because everything looked delicious). We ordered the chicken Caesar and the meatball Parmesan sub. Rae asked us if we had pickle pizza in . We don’t so based on her recommendation, we decided to try one slice and split it three ways so we could all try it (the picture is 1/3 of a slice - we added the hot pepper flakes!). This was a white pizza (no tomato sauce) with a delicious crust with just the right amount of chew, plentiful cheese and yummy pickles which perfectly complemented the other flavors. It was a real standout! The chicken Caesar was also delicious. The dressing was lemony and light and not very garlicky (which is how I prefer it). The romaine lettuce was fresh and crunchy and cut small (large pieces of romaine are a pet peeve of mine). The pieces of real chicken were plentiful as well. The meatball sub was delicious with a generous portion of meatballs and ooey gooey cheese. The bread was soft and fresh. As an aside, the bathrooms were spotless which is always a huge sign that the restaurant is very clean. We loved our entire experience at Aniello’s and we will definitely be back when passing through Corning.
As good as pizza in New York City - and that's high praise! The pizza was excellent. The flavor was perfect; it had just the right mix of seasoning and I felt no need to add anything. The crust was just right - soft enough to fold, but not soggy. We ordered at the counter and then the pizza was brought to our table. The prices were totally reasonable as was the size of the slices - generous but not ridiculous. There was ample seating and everything was clean. Our overall experience was fantastic. Next time we will know that not only is there free parking on the street in front of the restaurant, but there is ample free parking in the lot behind the restaurant.
It's a great pizza shop and more! Nice dining room and good service. The place is always busy. Cash is king here, but credit accepted. Nice atmosphere. Highly recommended! Whenever I'm in Corning, I stop here. Highly recommended!
Location
-
68 E Market St, Corning, NY 14830, United States Hotline: +1 607-962-2060
Welcome to Aniello's Pizzeria, a hidden gem nestled in the charming streets of Corning, NY. Located at 68 E Market St, this pizzeria is not just a stop, but a delightful destination for all pizza enthusiasts. With a dedicated phone line at +1 607-962-2060, they make it easy for you to reach out and savor what’s in store.
What sets Aniello's Pizzeria apart? The heartfelt reviews from satisfied customers paint a vivid picture. Scott J., on his way to the Finger Lakes, found not only great pizza but a friendly ambiance enhanced by efficient service. It's a perfect pit stop for travelers and locals alike.
Families and friends gather here, enjoying the hustle and bustle without delay. Thomas Thompson, MD, PhD, described his visit as a breeze, with a seamless ordering process followed by quick service at the table. The pizza crust was crispy and packed with flavor, notably on the Supreme Pizza that left everyone raving.
But the magic doesn’t stop there. Steve Delahunty shares that despite his skeptical expectations from a typical pizza place, Aniello's proved him wrong with stunning offerings. The food was kept warm in the pizza oven, ensuring that when served, it remained delightfully hot and satisfying. From traditional to Sicilian pizza, every bite promises authenticity.
For those with a taste for New York-style pizza, Ken Vastola attests to the quality you’d expect from a Brooklyn pizzeria. The blend of soft and crunchy crust achieved the perfect balance, showcasing their meticulous choice of ingredients. Coupled with Bryan Kruk's glowing 10/10 rating, it's clear that Aniello's is on par with the best.
Every visit is a reminder that craftsmanship in food can transcend expectations. Pricing here is reasonable, making the experience even sweeter. Whether you're a local or just passing through, Aniello's Pizzeria is more than just a meal; it's an experience worth reliving.